Skip to main content

Blogger silently drops comments submitted by Safari in embedded-comments mode

We've noticed that comments submitted from Apple Safari (Mac or iPhone) are dropped without any notification if the blog is set with Comment location = Embedded. Having set it to Pop up (I think), it worked. We're going to try some more tests. That's what this post is for!

From the comments testing we discovered some useful things:
  1. Using Comment location = embedded:
    • Is necessary to enable replying to specific comments.
    • Comments posted from Safari (laptop or iOS) are silently dropped. It looks to the person posting the comment that it went through, but the blog moderator sees no sign of it at all.
  2. Using Comment location = Pop up or Full page:
    • Inhibits option to reply to other comments – no comment threads
    • Enables comments from Safari
The trade-off is clear. Losing comments from people who think they submitted them successfully is not acceptable. Particularly from a prominent browser (currently estimated to be a bit less than 4% of users). I just hate to lose comment threading – it's essential to organized conversations – but it's much worse to not see someone's comment when they expect that I will (and did). So, bye-bye comment threads.

I hope Blogger (Google) fixes this.


anabisker said…
Safari on my phone
Ken Manheimer said…
Can't reply to Ana's comment, but can post an independent one.
Ken Manheimer said…
I just changed the comment settings to try to reenable replies (by enabling embedded) and by allowing comments from non-authenticated (non-google, including anonymous) users.

I suspect that the Safari problem will return, where comments submitted via Safari simply disappear without any warning. But we'll see.
anabisker said…
test from safari on macbook again
anabisker said…
maybe this will show up from safari on macbook

Popular posts from this blog

A Contemplative Movement Online Score

Barbara Dilley developed a shared dance/meditation practice called Contemplative Dance Practice – CDP, a "dancer's meditation hall". I've been exploring adaptation of this score for online sharing. The aim is to share meditation and movement across the gap of social distancing. (See below the score description for online meeting logistics and further info about the practices.)

(The framing of this score is a work in progress, continuing to change. Revision information is at the bottom.)
Score DescriptionThe score is divided into sections. At the beginning of each timed section the facilitator says which section it is and arranges for a bell to sound at the beginning and the end of that section. Opening Circle: Time for brief introductions / check-ins and to review the outline of the score (essentially, the bold headers below).Meditation: 15 minutes for stillness. In the original score the participants share sitting meditation. We invite whatever meditation method works …

Finger Lakes 2019-06 Biking: Overview and preliminary travel, Sunday, Monday June 2, 3

A few weeks ago I went with friends to the Finger Lakes area in upstate New York to camp and bike. It was an important opportunity and exploration for me, and wanting to write about the experience tipped me into starting a blog for these posts and others.

I'm including a table of contents of the trip postings towards the top of each one:
Finger Lakes 2019-06 Biking: Overview + preliminary travel, June 2, 3  ⇐ You are hereFinger Lakes 2019-06 Biking: Tuesday, June 4Finger Lakes 2019-06 Biking: Wednesday, June 5 - small incident, no bikingFinger Lakes 2019-06 Biking: Thursday, June 6Finger Lakes 2019-06 Biking: Friday, June 7 - campsite transition, no bikingFinger Lakes 2019-06 Biking: Saturday, June 8Finger Lakes 2019-06 Biking: Sunday, June 9Finger Lakes 2019-06 Biking: Trip Wrap-Up I love to travel by bike and to camp, and did some substantial outings summers during high school and college. During and after college I also redeveloped digestive problems that I had as an infant, an…

How and why multiple dispatch is good (Julia vs Python)

I'm really interested in the programming language, Julia, for several reasons, multiple dispatch being prominent among them. (I have some painful contortions in the Python implementation of my speculative programming project, Spherical. The contortions would not be necessary if Python was implemented with efficient multiple dispatch.) I thinkthis videogets at the essence of multiple dispatch's virtue.
Unfortunately it's a video, who has time for that? The distilled message is that the multiple dispatch (multimethods) solvesThe Expression Problem, and that's not a small thing. It's an oblique way of saying that it's a more comprehensive way to do procedural composition than other approaches, and so fundamentally has greater potential for comprehensibility. Composition is the essence of building stuff, and comprehensibility is the factor that governs collaboration between people - including, for that matter, of a person with themself over time.
I love Python, bu…